Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers: The Difference - Uncle Jim's Worm Farm

Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers: What’s the Difference?

Compost, Red Worms

When it comes to worms, there’s a whole world beneath our feet (or, shall we say, soil surface) waiting to be discovered. While they may all wriggle, squirm, and turn plant matter and food scraps into black gold, not all worms are created equal.

Today, we’ll dive into the curious case of the most well-known wigglers around – red wigglers vs. nightcrawlers. Are nightcrawlers and red wigglers the same thing? And, if not, what is the difference between nightcrawlers and red worms? What sets these two types of worms apart, and which should you choose for your composting or fishing adventures?

Time to find out!

Man holding red wigglers


Red Worms: Nature’s Tiny Compost Magicians

Imagine a bustling underground city where tiny superheroes work tirelessly to turn organic waste into nutrient-rich gold. That’s the world of Red Worms, scientifically known as Eisenia fetida, but known far and wide by many names such as tiger worms, trout worms, brandling worms, red wiggler worms, and so on, among fishing, composting, and worm enthusiasts.

No matter what you call them, these little compost wizards specialize in breaking down organic materials and turning them into worm castings – a fancy term for their nutrient-packed worm poop.

  • Perfect for Composting: Red Worms thrive in warm temperatures, making them the ideal choice for vermicomposting systems. Whether you have a small worm bin in your kitchen or a larger worm farm, these compost worms will happily gobble up your kitchen scraps and other organic materials, turning them into nutrient-rich compost in no time.
  • Wigglers with Benefits: Not only do these adult worms quickly break down organic waste materials, but they also improve soil structure and fertility. Their castings act as natural fertilizer, enriching your garden soils and providing a natural, eco-friendly, nutritive feast for your plants.
  • Eisenia fetida to the Rescue: Wiggler worms are true composting champions. They have a voracious appetite and reproduce at a rapid rate, which means they can devour a significant amount of organic waste and create an abundance of worm castings fast, making them popular composting worms.


Nightcrawlers: The Giants of the Earth

If Red wiggler worms are the tiny superheroes, then Nightcrawlers are the gentle giants of the worm world. Often referred to as common Earthworms, they belong to different species of Earthworms, such as Eisenia andrei, Eisenia hortensis, Lumbricus terrestris, or Lumbricus rubellus. Or, in plain English, African Nightcrawlers, Canadian Nightcrawlers, European nightcrawlers, etc.

Let’s focus on the common earthworm species, the mighty Lumbricus terrestris, and its wide range of skills, shall we? 

  • Bigger, Bolder Burrowers: Nightcrawlers are known for their impressive size, often growing several times larger than Red Worms. Their burrowing abilities are second to none, as they create intricate tunnels that improve soil aeration and drainage.
  • Cold Weather Connoisseurs: While Red wiggler worms prefer warmer temperatures, Nightcrawlers are built to withstand cold temperatures and climates. They can tolerate cooler temperatures and can often be found deep in the soil, snuggled up to stay warm during chilly winters.
  • Garden Guardians: These large species of earthworms are the heroes your garden needs. Their constant burrowing and feeding activities help mix and distribute organic matter throughout the soil, promoting a healthier root environment for your plants.


Summing It Up: Key Red Wiggler vs. Nightcrawler Differences to Remember

When it comes to the world of earthworms, these two mighty contenders take the stage. Although they may seem similar at first glance, beneath the soil lies a world of contrasting features. To help you navigate the fascinating worm realm, let’s recap the key differences between Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers that will make you a worm connoisseur in no time.

1. Size

What is the difference in size between Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers? Red Wiggler worms are smaller, usually measuring around 2-34 inches in length. On the other hand, Nightcrawlers are significantly larger, often growing up to 6-8 inches or even longer.

2. Physical

Wondering what are the main physical differences between Red Worms and Nightcrawlers? Besides their size difference, Red wigglers have a reddish-brown coloration throughout their body. However, the intensity of the red pigment can vary depending on their diet and environmental factors. Nightcrawlers have a darker brown or gray coloration, providing them with a more uniform appearance.

3. Habitat Preferences

Red Worms thrive in warmer temperatures, typically between 55°F and 77°F (12°C and 25°C). They are well-suited for indoor vermicomposting systems or controlled environments. Nightcrawlers, however, are more tolerant of cooler temperatures and can be found in various outdoor environments, even surviving colder winters.

4. Reproduction Rate

How do Red Worms and Nightcrawlers reproduce, and what are the differences in their reproductive processes? Red Worms are known for their rapid reproduction rate. A single Red Worm can produce several cocoons containing multiple baby worms. This high rate of reproduction enables Red Worm populations to grow quickly. Nightcrawlers, on the other hand, reproduce at a slower pace and produce fewer offspring.

5. Burrowing Behavior

How do the behaviors of Red Worms and Nightcrawlers differ in terms of feeding and burrowing? Nightcrawlers are excellent burrowers and create complex tunnels in the soil, contributing to soil aeration and drainage. Red Worms, while they do burrow to some extent, are not as proficient in burrowing as Nightcrawlers.


Wriggle Buddies Similarities: Exploring the Shared Traits of Red Worms and Nightcrawlers

Let’s put the Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers showdown to rest for a sec. After all, the rockstars of the soil stage, Red Worms and Nightcrawlers, both hail from the same earthworm class Oligochaeta and share more features in common than just their slimy charm and composting skills.

They both have a tube-shaped body, a segmented structure, and a closed circulatory system, as well as a coelom, which serves as their hydrostatic skeleton. Moreover, these two species of worms are hermaphrodites and reproduce through clitella when two join together. These two types of worms live in the top few inches of the soil, feeding on dead organic matter. gardener showing his earthworms

In doing so, they aerate and drain the soil by consuming leaf and other dead plant material near the surface where bacteria or fungi have decomposed. Such activity encourages more microorganisms to inhabit and thrive in this area, which improves its quality for sustaining plant life. Thus, both red worms and nightcrawlers play an integral part in promoting healthy soil for plants to grow effectively. Oh, and they both make great fishing bait and mealworms, too!


Can You Mix Nightcrawlers and Red Worms?

Now that we know all about Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers, you might be wondering if these two worm species can coexist peacefully. Let’s tackle some of your burning questions. 

  • Can You Put Nightcrawlers and Red Wigglers Together? Absolutely! While Nightcrawlers and Red Wigglers have different preferences and behaviors, they are closely related and can live together in the same environment without any major issues. Just make sure the conditions are suitable for both species.
  • Can Nightcrawlers Live with Red Worms? Yes, they can! Nightcrawlers are generally more tolerant of a cooler range of temperatures, while Red Worms prefer warmer conditions. If you provide a controlled environment with a moderate temperature range, both species can happily cohabitate and make great compost worms.
  • Do Nightcrawlers Eat Other Worms? Or better yet, will night crawlers eat red wigglers? Nightcrawlers have a diverse diet that includes organic matter and decaying plant material. While they are not typically known to be cannibalistic, in some cases, larger Nightcrawlers may consume their smaller Red cousins. However, this behavior is extremely rare and occurs when food sources are scarce. So, just make sure to keep their tummies full, and don’t sweat it!


Making the Right Choice: Which Type of Worm Is Better for Composting? 

Are red wigglers or nightcrawlers better for composting? Now that we’ve examined the distinct qualities of nightcrawlers vs. red wigglers, let’s explore which worm species is the better choice for your composting adventures.

With their burrowing prowess, Nightcrawlers play a supporting role in aeration and organic matter processing, particularly in larger-scale composting systems or outdoor environments. However, Red Wiggler worms take the crown with their efficient digestion, adaptability to controlled environments, and rapid population growth.

Red Worms are composting maestros and are the top pick for indoor vermicomposting systems due to their knack for warmer temperatures. They have a remarkable appetite for a range of organic waste materials and reproduce at a rapid rate, making them efficient waste processors. If you’re looking to create nutrient-rich worm castings and compost piles Red Worms are your go-to companions.

Can I Use Nightcrawlers for Vermicomposting?

Sure! While Nightcrawlers may not be the top pick for traditional vermicomposting systems due to their slower rate of reproduction, they still efficiently contribute to soil improvement and organic matter breakdown. If you have larger-scale composting needs or an outdoor compost pile, Nightcrawlers are a great choice and can assist in aerating the pile and speeding up decomposition.

How About Fishing?

Wondering which of these squirmers make the best worms for fishing

Many types of nightcrawler worms, such as the Canadian and European Nightcrawlers, are the go-to choice for many anglers when it comes to fishing worms. Their larger size and substantial body weight make them enticing to bigger fish seeking a hearty meal. From bass to trout, Nightcrawlers are a favorite among fishing enthusiasts.

However, bigger doesn’t always equal better, and if you’re after smaller fish, such as Bluegills, Crappie, and Perch, Red wiggler worms make excellent fishing bait worms. Their small size and lively, wiggly movements make them irresistible to fish species that scare more easily. So, whether you’re casting a line in a freshwater stream or angling at the beach, Red Worms are a reliable choice for reeling in an awesome catch.

Can Red Worms and Nightcrawlers be used interchangeably as fishing bait? While both are popular choices, their differences make them more suitable for specific fishing scenarios. Assess the fish species you’re targeting and your fishing conditions to determine the best choice for your needs.


The Final Red Worms vs. Nightcrawlers Verdict: It All Comes Down to Personal Preference

When it comes to choosing between Red Worms and Nightcrawlers, there’s no definitive right or wrong answer. It all boils down to personal preference and the specific needs of your composting or fishing endeavors. Consider the following factors when deciding which type of worms to buy:

  • Ideal Conditions & Use: Red Worms thrive in warmer temperatures, making them a great choice for indoor vermicomposting. If you have a small-scale vermicomposting system, such as a worm bin in your kitchen, tiny Red Worms are a perfect fit. Nightcrawlers, on the other hand, tolerate cooler temperatures and are better suited for outdoor composting systems or reeling in big fish.
  • Rate of Reproduction: If you’re looking for a worm species that reproduce rapidly and can consume a significant amount of organic waste, Red Worms are the winners. Nightcrawlers reproduce slower, but their larger size and burrowing capabilities make them valuable in certain composting scenarios.
  • Size and Availability: Consider the size of the worms you prefer for fishing. Nightcrawlers, with their larger size, may be more appealing to fish seeking a substantial meal. Additionally, take into account the availability of the worms in your area. Red Worms, being popular composting worms, are often readily available from worm farmers or online sellers.


Unlock the Power of the Oligochaeta Dream Team: Buy Live Worms Today

Ultimately, the choice between red wigglers vs. nightcrawlers for composting or fishing comes down to your specific requirements and preferences. Both species have unique advantages and can contribute to the success of your endeavors. So, whether you’re building a worm farm to create nutrient-rich castings or heading out for a fishing expedition, consider the qualities and characteristics of Red Worms and Nightcrawlers to make an informed decision.

Remember, Red Worms are the composting superheroes, tirelessly turning organic waste into black gold at lightning speed, while Nightcrawlers are the gentle giants of the earth, enriching soils and attracting fish with their larger size. Choose the worms that best suit your needs, and let these remarkable creatures enhance your composting or fishing adventures!

You can find both at Uncle Jim’s farm (as well as all the supplies you need) and get them delivered right to your doorstep, live and wiggly. Happy composting and tight lines!


4 thoughts on “Red Wigglers vs. Nightcrawlers: What’s the Difference?

  1. So what is an earthworm? At the bait store the earthworm cost more than the “Wiggler” or “night crawler”. And I have also found that warm farmers are a lot like preachers, they like to use different names that are ultimately the same thing. But great article, did learn a lot. In Florida with our temperatures I am assuming the red worm, red Wiggler is the better option for raising worms.

  2. Considering purchasing some red wrigglers for our plant beds. Do I need to ‘feed’ them with scraps? It would be hard to put scraps in our beds, since I try to keep them well manicured. Any suggestions?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Send this to a friend